Instagram is one of those platforms that can either work wonders for your real estate business or leave you wondering if anyone is even seeing your posts. You spend time crafting content, picking the right photos, and sharing valuable tips, yet somehow, the engagement just isn’t there. It’s frustrating, but here’s the thing: it’s not always about working harder, it’s about working smarter.
If your posts aren’t getting the traction you want, it might not be the algorithm working against you, it could be small mistakes in your strategy that are holding you back. The good news? These mistakes are fixable. Let’s break down what might be killing your Instagram reach and how you can turn things around starting now.
Your Content Isn’t Grabbing Attention
One of the biggest mistakes real estate agents make is not creating content that stands out. Instagram is a visual platform, and if your posts don’t immediately grab attention, people will scroll right past them. If you’re only sharing listing photos or text-heavy graphics, you might not be getting the engagement you’re hoping for. A better approach is to mix things up with video content, behind-the-scenes peeks, and lifestyle shots that tell a story. People love to see what happens beyond the listing, so showing home tours, neighborhood highlights, or even a quick glimpse into your daily routine can create more interest.
You’re Not Using Video (Especially Reels)
Another major issue is ignoring video content, especially Reels. Instagram has made it clear that video gets priority in the algorithm, and yet many agents still hesitate to incorporate it into their marketing.
If you’re not comfortable being on camera, start with simple faceless Reels. Show off different features of a property, highlight common home-buying mistakes, or share quick tips for sellers. You can use trending audio or captions to make the content engaging without having to speak directly on camera. Video doesn’t have to be complicated, but it does need to be a part of your strategy if you want to improve your reach.
You’re Posting Inconsistently
Inconsistent posting is another thing that can hurt your visibility. Instagram favors accounts that show up regularly, so if you’re posting inconsistently, your content is less likely to be seen. Instead of posting whenever you remember, set a schedule that works for you and stick to it. You don’t have to post daily, but aim for at least three to four times a week to keep your audience engaged. Creating a content calendar can help you stay organized and avoid last-minute scrambling for post ideas.
Your Captions Aren’t Encouraging Engagement
The way you write your captions also plays a huge role in engagement. If your captions are too generic or sound robotic, people won’t feel compelled to interact. Instead of just saying “New listing! DM me for details,” try making it more engaging by adding a personal touch. You could say something like, “This backyard is an entertainer’s dream! Would you rather have a pool or a fire pit?” Questions encourage conversation, and Instagram rewards posts with higher engagement by showing them to more people.
You’re Not Engaging With Your Audience
A common mistake that often gets overlooked is failing to engage with your audience. Posting is just one part of the equation—if you’re not responding to comments, answering DMs, or engaging with other accounts, Instagram won’t prioritize your content. Spend at least 10 to 15 minutes a day interacting with your audience. Reply to comments on your posts, engage with other local businesses, and join conversations in your niche. This small habit can make a big difference in how Instagram ranks your content.
You’re Not Using Hashtags and Location Tags Correctly
Many agents also struggle with using hashtags and location tags correctly. These are essential tools that help Instagram categorize your content and show it to the right people. If you’re not using them at all, or if you’re choosing hashtags that are too broad, you’re missing an opportunity to reach a wider audience. Focus on a mix of location-based hashtags, industry-specific ones, and those that relate to your content. For example, instead of just using #RealEstate, try #YourCityHomes, #MoveToYourCity, or #FirstTimeHomebuyerTips. Adding a location tag to every post also increases the chances of your content being seen by people in your area.
Final Thoughts
Instagram is constantly evolving, and staying ahead requires regular adjustments to your strategy. If your reach has been declining, take a step back and look at what you might need to change. The key to success on Instagram isn’t just posting more—it’s about posting smarter. Focus on content that grabs attention, mix in video, stay consistent, engage with your audience, and use the right tags to boost visibility. Small changes can lead to big improvements, and the more you fine-tune your approach, the better results you’ll see.
Your Inbox Deserves Better!
